3 Comments
User's avatar
Jon Boyd's avatar

This essay does not distinguish North American zoning from zoning regimes in other parts of the world. Sonia Hirt's *Zoned in the USA* argues that North American zoning is unique compared to peer countries. Maybe we are uniquely bad at zoning.

Zachary Mitchell's avatar

Great Article! There's no question: Euclid must die.

Back in the post Euclid 1950s, suburban planners said “I know that car suburbs are the ideal lifestyle, I am going to encode it into law”.

Euclid was harmful not just because of the obvious stuff (single family zoning, ect), but for the deeper principled reason that it allowed personal preferences for development to be enforced on private property with police power

Urbanists that want to encode their development preferences into law - form based codes, objective design standards, architecture standards - are doing the same thing with a different font. Maybe with a better font, but still doing the same bad practice.

Good legal doctrine allows people to choose. It allows them to choose their lifestyle, their building form, their architecture style, ect.

Lee Nellis's avatar

Of course zoning doesn’t result in the places we want. It’s one part of a complex, continuous conversation. How you regulate land use doesn’t matter much if you don’t have infrastructure. And how you do infrastructure, especially streets and trails, makes a big difference. The design and management of public spaces makes a big difference. Environmental protection (which requires good zoning, but goes beyond) makes a big difference. At the root of everything, there is leadership (or the lack of it) and how it is cultivated. Your city obviously struggled with land use. Ours initiated zoning reform over the course of two years, 20 years ago, and is still chipping away, but there’ve been great results. In our case, other things are harder. Creating a master narrative that eliminating zoning will somehow result in great places may vent frustration, but to the extent anyone is paying attention, it just undercuts a lot of hard work.